28519c5d-b233-407f-b570-4757726d4b2e
GianLuca

GianLuca

Benefits of Hedging Freight with the Spot Market

Benefits of Hedging Freight with the Spot Market While it is common for companies to contract all their freight the Supply Chain has been anything but common over the last 20 years.  Finding the balance between competitive rates, guaranteed capacity and top service in volatile markets is a demanding job.  Contracting freight has traditionally been the go-to method for managing transportation needs, providing a predictable and stable way to handle shipments.  Some companies do this to stay consistent with the budget. However, maintaining a budget should not keep you from exploring cost-saving initiatives in a hyper competitive marketplace.  By keeping a percentage of your freight in the spot market, you introduce a valuable hedge against fluctuating rates, enhancing flexibility, and mitigating risk. The Case for Not Fully Contracting Freight Relying solely on contracted freight may seem like a safe choice, but it can leave companies vulnerable to missed cost-saving opportunities and limited flexibility. It’s a natural approach to maintain stability in a volatile market but exploring the spot market with just a small portion of your freight can be a way to explore and hedge the market. Contract rates are typically fixed for a set period, which can be beneficial in a stable market but could lead to overspending if rates dip. The spot market allows you to access real-time pricing, which may be advantageous during periods of lower demand or when capacity loosens. By not committing all freight to long-term contracts, companies can take advantage of market conditions and respond more swiftly to cost-saving opportunities. The Benefits of Hedging with the Spot Market
  1. Risk Mitigation through Diversification
    • Holding some freight for the spot market helps further diversify your transportation strategy which reduces your dependency on contracted carriers.  This is especially helpful during disruptions or peak seasons when contracted rates may rise.
    • Diversification also allows you to respond quickly if a contracted carrier faces issues, such as service delays, bankruptcy, or strikes, providing you with alternative options and minimizing potential impacts on your operations while hopefully at the same time reducing cost.
  2. Leveraging Real-Time Market Trends
    • The spot market allows you to respond to real-time price fluctuations and trends. For example, during off-peak seasons, spot rates can fall below contracted rates, enabling you to access lower-cost transportation. This dynamic approach can offer a cost savings initiative to increase net margins and gain a competitive advantage.
    • Accessing the spot market also enables you to gather pricing data which can be helpful in future contract negotiations while also staying on top of your market knowledge.
  3. Increased Negotiation Power
    • By maintaining a blend of contracted and spot freight, you hold leverage during rate negotiations. When a portion of your volume is placed in the spot market, you can approach contract negotiations with the knowledge of real-time rates, potentially securing more competitive long-term contracts.  Carriers will likely also realize you are well informed on market conditions and be less likely to offer higher rates at the onset of your negotiations.
    • Carriers value long-term contracts as they provide predictable volume, but they also understand that shippers have options and having options helps to maintain control. Knowing that a percentage of your freight will always remain in the spot market can encourage carriers to offer more favorable terms.
  4. Vendor Options
    • By keeping a portion of your business in the spot market it will allow you the opportunity to gather data on additional Carriers regarding their capacity, service levels and other
    • A spot carrier can also be a good way to find a future contracted carrier
How Much Should You Allocate to the Spot Market? Determining the right balance between contracted and spot freight depends on several factors: industry dynamics, seasonal demand, and overall risk tolerance. A common approach is to allocate 10-25% of freight to the spot market. This percentage allows for flexibility while maintaining enough contracted volume to ensure stable capacity. Higher allocations may be beneficial for industries with highly fluctuating demand, while lower percentages may be more appropriate for businesses needing higher stability. Best Practices for Implementing a Spot Market Strategy
  1. Monitor Market Trends
    • Use data analytics to keep an eye on market conditions, rates, and capacity trends, making it easier to make informed decisions on when to shift volumes into the spot market.
  2. Work with a Reliable Network of Carriers
    • Establish a network of trusted spot market carriers to ensure reliable service quality and on-time performance.
  3. Utilize Technology and Data
    • Leveraging tools like Transportation Management Systems (TMS) can make it easier to blend spot and contracted freight seamlessly, optimizing route and carrier selection based on cost and availability.
  4. Hedge your own Hedge
    • Negotiating a contract which allows you the “option” of putting up to 25% of your business in the spot market is a 2nd hedge from being exposed to a market which might not be favorable (increasing prices) to transitioning your contracted freight for spot
    • In doing so make sure to work with your Carriers regarding your forecast in a way that will not have them holding extra capacity for you if there is not a need.
Conclusion Contracting all your freight might seem like a safe approach, but it can ultimately limit flexibility and cost-effectiveness. By introducing a calculated percentage of freight to the spot market, companies gain flexibility, can better manage costs, and reduce risk exposure. In a volatile and dynamic transportation industry, hedging with the spot market is not just a strategy—it’s a competitive advantage that enables companies to adapt to shifting market conditions and meet customer demands efficiently.   USXports can support you in any spot or contracting needs.

Share this post

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
temp mail
temp mail
3 months ago

Your blog is a testament to your passion for your subject matter. Your enthusiasm is infectious, and it’s clear that you put your heart and soul into every post. Keep up the fantastic work!

Gianluca Fedelini
Gianluca Fedelini
2 months ago
Reply to  temp mail

Thank you !